The Recycling Product News team was in Toronto this week for the Waste & Recycling Expo Canada (aka CWRE) annual trade show and convention. We interviewed representatives from some of the innovative companies exhibiting on the show floor.
Highlights from the 19th annual Paper & Plastics Recycling Conference NA
State of end markets including China and contamination challenges facing the industry top of the agenda in Chicago
This year's 19th edition of the Paper & Plastics Recycling Conference North America, held in Chicago from October 17 through 19th and produced by the Recycling Today Media Group, was a very informative, well organized and well attended event, and a good reflection of the mixed feelings currently being expressed by the industry with respect to the state of paper and plastics recycling. On the technology side of the industry, things are largely positive. Business is good. From the latest plastics additive and stabilizing technologies designed to enhance the physical properties and thereby the quality of recycled plastics for compounders and other reprocessors, to the significant advances in sorting, screening and other equipment being put forward by leading manufacturers, it is clear that there is solid demand, and excellent solutions available to help profitably create better quality recycled materials from challenging input streams. The advances in this sector are in fact rapid and ongoing. The latest robotic and optical sorting, coupled with artificially intelligent (AI) "learning" technologies, are particularly impressive - making it difficult for anyone to deny that high-tech materials sorting has a huge role to play in the future of this industry.
Where the recycling industry is feeling less positive is with respect to mixed paper and plastics end markets specifically. The topic of how the industry can best adjust to the new world order without China as a key market for these materials was at the top of the agenda all week in Chicago. While equipment manufacturers and technology providers as well as recyclers which do not deal in mixed plastics or paper remain relatively positive, processors of mixed paper and mixed plastics - especially numbers 3 through 7 - are feeling the crunch most intensely. Inbound contamination levels of mixed materials captured mainly through single-stream programs are as high as 20% or more in many jurisdictions, which means producing extremely pure material is costly and inefficient.
• One highlight of the week was at the PSI Session Wednesday, sponsored and hosted by long-time conference partner, ISRI's PSI (Paper Stock Industries) and moderated by industry veteran, conference co-founder and paper recycling expert Bill Moore, President of Moore & Associates. Sustainability representatives from HAVI/McDonalds and Starbucks participated in a counterpoint format with two experienced MRF owner/operators and Linda Leone, VP, Northeast Region, Recycle, for Westrock - the paperboard mill operator and leading global paper and packaging firm - which does accept post-consumer fibre cups at eight mills in the U.S.
The question: can post-consumer one-time use polymer and fibre-based coffee cups be included in the mix at the recycling plant? Currently, very few communities in North America accept the material. The restaurant brand representatives made great points about the efforts both McDonalds and Starbucks have made recently to try to engage with both consumers and the recycling industry to make their coffee cups more sustainable overall and acceptable for recyclers, including a partnership with the Foodservice Packaging Institute. Both companies are working hard to this end certainly. Currently, there are eight mills run by Westrock, as well as plants in Vancouver, Seattle and Washington DC, that are accepting their latest post-consumer coffee cups.
By the end of the session however, after the recycling industry representatives responded with their experiences with post-consumer fibre coffee cups, it was clear that from their perspective, there is a long, long way to go. The issues, including food and liquid contamination with this category of container was the first issue pointed to which has so far contributed to reasons why both of the MRF recycling panelists (Mark Badger of Canada Fibers, and Kerry Getter of Texas-based Balcones Resources) have not accepted the material to date. Both were adamant that until post-consumer coffee cups (a mix of paper, ink and polymer coating) are profitable to recycle with sustainable end markets, it just wasn't an economically feasible category of container to accept at their plants.
"For us, it's about cost of recovery and the ROI," said Balcones' Kerry Getter, "and it needs to be good enough for the mill."
Mark Badger from Canada Fibers also mentioned the issue of trying to process paper that is saturated with ink, and which includes an inside polymer coating. The ink contaminates, to varying degrees, the paper portion of the cup. He pointed out that because there are three different materials in a cup, it can produce negative results during processing, including bale contamination as well as "confused" optical sorters, which can have trouble identifying what they are detecting. This can result in cups going to residue and then to landfill. His suggestion was that if cups were made with two layers of polycoat, both outside (with ink on the poly rather than the paper) and inside, with a layer of paper between, it would be a much better scenario for recyclers that need to produce very pure fibre output. Also, he noted, there needs to be the creation of a domestic closed-loop for the product, so it can go directly back into the manufacturer of new cups, and that for it to truly work, every manufacturer of single-use cups needs to produce cups to the same standards. He reemphasized that recyclers simply cannot process material unless it is cost-effective.
• At a Thursday session titled "Alternate Markets to China - India, Indonesia, Vietnam, Mexico and Latin America", panelists included Steve Sutta, President, Sutta Co. (U.S.), Rogelio Silva, Director, Continental Paper Grading (Mexico) and Sung Soo Lee, Hansol Paper (South Korea).
From the start, it was clear that, according to all three panelists, for mixed plastics and paper, there are simply no viable alternative markets that can act as a substitute for the loss of Chinese end markets. Alternate markets including Vietnam and India have already been saturated (in as little as six months) by the large volumes of mixed paper that cannot go to China. These markets are congested and there is a lack of infrastructure and capacity. So then the question becomes: why would any nation want to continue to take mixed, low-grade, hard-to-recover-for-high-value materials? There is no question that China has good reason not to take mixed materials which cannot be easily recycled, and which ultimately contribute to landfill "waste", as the country strives to clean up one of the most polluted environments on the planet. Why would other countries want to continue to take contaminated recyclables?
"There is no market for mixed plastic, and it's not coming back," said Steve Sutta frankly. "Everyone is overwhelmed. The recycling industry needs to advocate for itself. The Exxons and the Duponts, the multi-billion dollar companies need to figure out a way to re-use the materials that they are producing, and take care of the problem they have created.... The party is over."
I thought this was very well said, and I could definitely feel the frustration echoed on behalf of mixed plastics processors via Mr. Sutta's comments.
On the paper side, Rogelio Silva commented on the capacity of Mexican markets for mixed paper as being way too low to provide a home for the tonnage that now needs a market on an annual basis. "Paper consumption is low in Latin America," he said. "The paper industry has to rethink itself, redesign its systems and processes. I think this is the moment to change what we do." He added that in Mexico, as in the U.S., and Canada, mills are being built, but it will take time to create the capacity.
Interestingly, at the end of the session, one of the audience members stated that he is from Belgium, and wonders why there is so much talk about a lack of international end markets, when he sees many mills empty across the EU, and looking for material. Another asked the question: why are we focused on getting to an impossible purity specification for mixed paper and plastics of as low as 0.5% for an international market, and not entirely focused on building domestic mill and paper making capacity. This then raised the question as to how much the issues we currently face are economic, and how much they are political. Good question.
• Bottom line takeaway for this Editor based on four days at this year's Paper & Plastics Recycling Conference North America: the recycling and waste management industry collectively needs to undergo significant change, monumental even, beyond the level of change that was made when the industry went from dual stream to single-stream collection, or when we saw the resulting MRF-boom of the 2000s. Following are a few more specific takeaways from last week in Chicago.
PPRC TAKEAWAY 1: It remains clear that public education is needed as a first and ongoing step, so that all waste generators, residential and commercial, are engaged and understand the importance of helping to sort recyclables properly - so they retain the highest value possible and the industry can remain sustainable. If there needs to be penalties for non-compliance, or rewards for compliance, then so be it. But this is only one of the changes needed. One part of the equation cannot be the sole focus, and it would be naïve to put all the responsibility on waste generators to diminish recyclables contamination to adequate levels for profitable recovery.
PPRC TAKEAWAY 2: There are also serious issues with labour in the recycling plant, including pickers, (and drivers on the hauling and collection side) which need to paid more so the industry can attract and retain good people. Automation is the future, but a revised, highly trained labour force is also needed. How well this is managed will play a key part in any updated version of the industry that is to come. Some MRF operators, at the Tuesday MRF Operations Forum (which preceded the Paper & Plastics Recycling Conference) told me their picking line turnover is as much as 30% monthly. It is a tough job to sort society's discarded materials, especially when minimum wage and contracted workers are the industry standard in many MRFs.
PPRC TAKEAWAY 3: Perhaps the most important fundamental change that is needed in order to update our industry is that manufacturers of products - many of which are multi-million and multi-billion dollar entities - change the way they manufacture goods. Goods and products need to be made from more homogenous materials, so that recyclers can profitably process those goods at the end of their life, and recover their value. Without this change, it is honestly hard to believe that the industry can be sustained. There has to be some acceptance of responsibility at the ground level - where products with a pre-determined total lifecycle - are made. This means those producers of materials need to pay more for recyclable design and for the end-of-life management of their products -- with the help of government at all levels - in order to sustain a profitable recycling industry. Without a profitable, functioning recycling industry, eventually waste will become overwhelming and everyone will have a very large problem. Beyond corporations, governments in particular need to realize that waste management, if we think long-term (and it need not be too long) is as essential (or nearly) as our roads and sewer systems, for example. They are all three a necessity for a well -functioning society, but roads and sewer systems are funded by tax dollars in every city on the planet, without question. Management of "waste" needs to be thought of similarly going forward, through funding and tax-based support of the recycling industry.
Perhaps it is naïve optimism to think that governments and the producers of goods will somehow realize that global waste management is currently at a crisis point. Even if end markets in China suddenly reappear, we only have to look at the Pacific ocean garbage patch to confirm that there is a crisis in managing global waste. Whatever the case may be, the paper and plastics recycling industry, the collectors and especially the recycling plant operators which have been set up and are greatly invested in order to deal with mixed paper and plastics, are straining under the weight of carrying nearly the entire burden of dealing with these low-return materials once discarded. The recycling industry could use some serious attention and cooperation from all stakeholders, especially the producers of goods which continue to reap the rewards of their massive profits without taking full responsibility for their full cost.
Put simply, the recycling industry needs work. It needs help managing a huge job that is an absolute necessity for all of us. It would seem, based on the conference last week, that there is a long way to go, but that our industry is working extremely hard to reinforce the message, advocate and enact real change. RPN
More from Paper Recycling
While the recycling industry faces challenges stemming from China's restrictions and bans, things are looking up in the form of increased investment from both MRFs and end markets. Today, there are more opportunities than ever for food and beverage cartons to find a second life in products ranging from paper products like towels, writing paper, tissues and cups, to eco-friendly building materials.
FCC's new single-stream facility in Houston revitalizing neighbourhood while cleaning up contaminated stream
Running since March of this year, FCC Environmental Services has opened up a new single stream plant in Houston, TX. The plant will accept residential single stream material from throughout Houston for a minimum of 15 years. FCC has also made the city the new home of their U.S. corporate headquarters, settling into the East Houston community. The district has embraced the recycling facility as a welcome investment in an underdeveloped part of town. FCC has employed many local citizens at the site, including some from a second-chance labor provider, to really make themselves part of the local landscape.
The first robotic sorting systems in Canada were installed in the Fall of 2018 by Machinex, at the Sani-Éco MRF in Granby, Quebec, and soon after, at the Chatham-Kent Recycling MRF in Merlin, Ontario. At both facilities Machinex installed a double robotic sorting system, using two SamurAI robotic sorting units placed in succession on a single line. This summer, Machinex installed three more robotic sorting units at a MRF in Toronto and one machine at a MRF in Winnipeg.
Since its inception in 2010, the Carton Council of Canada (CCC) has worked to deliver long-term solutions to help increase carton recovery and recycling in Canada.
In the last several years, North American recycling operations have seen overseas markets for fibre products that have historically been reliable become much more difficult to access. Rising global purity standards are either virtually unobtainable using traditional sorting and separation methods, or they are too costly to meet using options such as adding additional manual sorters.
In apparent retaliation to the U.S. Administration's recent announcement of tariffs on Chinese products to begin in September and December, the Chinese government announced last week its intent to levy additional tariffs on $75 billion worth of goods from the United States. These tariffs add on to those already in place from announcements in 2018.
Santa Barbara County, California has buried about 200,000 tons of annual trash in its Tajiguas Landfill since 1967. The landfill was on track to hit its capacity in about six years from now, until the announcement of a renewable energy project that is expected to extend its life by an additional decade.
This past spring, BACE, LLC announced the launch of the first-ever, fully-integrated Ecosystem for balers and compactors, powered by the IntelliBACE Platform. This August, BACE announced issuance by the United States Patent and Trade Office (USPTO) of US Patent No.: US 10,377,518, which protects the IntelliBACE Platform.
While headlines over the past few years might lead some to believe otherwise, the reality is that Americans say they are still recycling at the same rate, despite having little confidence that their recyclables actually get recycled. A national poll conducted by Mason-Dixon on behalf of the U.S. based Carton Council showed that 85% of respondents report they recycle.
In June, RPN had the opportunity to visit Canada's only turnkey MRF technology provider, Machinex, at the company's headquarters in Plessisville, Quebec. The company is very busy, with multiple MRF design/installation and retrofit projects across Canada currently and through 2020 - which will mark Machinex' 50th anniversary in manufacturing.
merQbiz, a solutions and analytics provider for buyers and sellers in the recovered paper (RCP) industry, introduces BaleVision, providing companies actionable insights into their RCP quality. Combining a leading quality assessment tool with comprehensive data, BaleVision helps RCP buyers maximize supplier performance and sellers earn a fair price for their product.
Republic Services is tackling head-on the crisis of overly contaminated waste streams in today's MRFs. With current residential contamination levels reaching as high as 30% or more, it is critical that processors send a clear message to the community about what is accepted in the recycling program, while also employing the most advanced, flexible technology on the market to separate this evolving stream.
A new report from NPC Partners is now available in the U.S. and Europe through Atlanta-based paper recycling consulting firm Moore & Associates. NPC Partners is a global consultancy based in Hong Kong with offices in Beijing, Shanghai and Atlanta. NPC Partners is committed to assisting the pulp and paper industry innovate and grow based on winning strategies and new market insights.
June 12-13, Machinex and the Carton Council of Canada invited Recycling Product News to Quebec. The first stop was a tour of the Machinex manufacturing facility and HQ in Plessisville, about 2 hours East of Montreal. Secondly, the Carton Council of Canada and Machinex hosted customers and press for a tour of Sani-Éco's MRF in Granby, Quebec where Machinex recently installed the company's latest Mach Hyspec optical sorting technology, along with a pair of SamurAI robotic sorting units for handling both cartons and PET/HDPE plastic.
Last month, in an effort to crack down on illegal shipments, the Indonesian government imposed new regulations on imports of recovered paper. The rules included a 0.5% contamination limit and 100% pre-shipment inspections, including separating containers into bales. The government has now announced that it will instead use the Institute of Scrap Recycling Industries (ISRI) specifications for recovered paper which set a standard of 1-2% for prohibitives and 3-4% for outhrows. It is also using the specifications to define its use of the word "homogenous" in describing the condition of bales.
After a two-month construction and installation period, Area Recycling launched its new state of the art material recovery system this week. The facility expansion and equipment upgrade represents a $3.5 million dollar business investment for PDC, Area Recycling's parent company, based out of Illinois.
Moore & Associates, a paper recycling consulting firm based in Atlanta, recently announced the availability of the 2019 China Recovered Paper Market & Policy Advisory Report. From Hong Kong-based NPC Partners (a premier and innovative consultancy firm for the pulp & paper industry), the new report presents a view from inside China, including insights and analysis on China's new recovered paper policies, markets and global impacts.
ZWS Waste Solutions, LLS (ZWS) of Rochester, Massachusetts, has opened one of the most advanced recycling facilities in the world.
The City of Lethbridge, Alberta held the grand opening of their new single-stream material recovery facility on May 8. According to Machinex, their sorting system at the facility, commissioned in mid-April, will allow the City to process residential recycling materials generated by a new blue cart program that is currently being set up.
Machinex attended the official ceremony this week marking the major upgrade of the Sani-Éco material recovery facility located in Granby, Province of Quebec, Canada. The owners of the recycling management company reiterated their trust in Machinex, which provided them their sorting center more than 18 years ago. This modernization will allow an increase of their current sorting capacity in addition to bringing a direct improvement to the quality of the fibers produced.
Bulk Handling Systems (BHS) has launched the Max-AI AQC-C, a solution that is comprised of Max-AI VIS (for Visual Identification System) and at least one collaborative robot (CoBot). CoBots are designed to work safely alongside people which allows the AQC-C to be quickly and easily placed into existing Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs). BHS launched the original Max-AI AQC (Autonomous Quality Control) at WasteExpo in 2017. At this year's show, our next generation AQC will be on display along with the AQC-C.
RePower South (RPS) has begun processing material at the company's new recycling and recovery facility in Berkeley County, South Carolina. The recycling system, provided by Eugene, Oregon-based Bulk Handling Systems (BHS), is one of the most advanced in the world. The highly automated system is capable of processing more than 50-tons-per-hour (tph) of mixed waste to recover recyclables and produce a fuel feedstock.
Machinex recently carried out a full design review of the MACH Hyspec optical sorter. As part of this process, the decision was made to totally revamp the overall appearance of the unit.
Niagara Recycling was incorporated in 1978 as a non-profit social enterprise company. Norm Kraft started with the company in 1989, became CEO in 1993, and has never looked back.
Only a few years ago the standards for recycled paper and board in China were not high. As a massive importer, China is now known to reject entire container loads based upon one inferior bale. Responding to this reality, Valorizaciones Vilar Guillén SL (V V G) set out to streamline their entire business to deliver against tight specifications, earning respect and repeat business as a result.
Between summer 2017 and 2018, Dem-Con Materials Recovery in Shakopee, Minnesota retrofitted their single-stream MRF with three new MSS CIRRUS optical sorters for fiber from CP Group. The units increase recovery, improve product quality and reduce sorter headcount on the fiber QC. A fourth MSS CIRRUS sensor is currently in production and will install this summer.
MSS, Inc., the optical sorting division of CP Group, has received a patent for their PrecisionFlow eject hood for optical sorters.
Canada Fibers awarded contracts to design, build and operate two technologically advanced recycling facilities
Canada Fibers Limited (CFL) has been awarded two contracts to design, build and operate advanced single-stream post-consumer Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs) in Winnipeg, Manitoba and Peel, Ontario. The Company is constructing an 80 thousand square foot greenfield facility in Winnipeg and is retrofitting the Region of Peel's existing MRF. Both projects involve advancements to recovery technologies in response to increasingly rigorous quality standards from industries utilizing post-consumer recyclable materials.
Machinex and Canada Fibers partnership to result in two of the most technologically advanced single-stream facilities in North America
Toronto-based Canada Fibers Ltd. (CFL) is building two single-stream recycling facilities in 2019 that will include the most advanced, high-tech fibre and plastics sorting and recovery systems in Canada. In Winnipeg, Manitoba, a completely new 30-tonnes-per-hour facility (approximately 80,000 square feet) is currently under construction and scheduled to open in the fall. In the Region of Peel, Ontario, the existing Peel Integrated Waste Management Facility MRF, owned by the Region, will be retrofitted for 31.5-tonnes-per-hour capacity, with the updated facility (approximately 85,000 square feet) scheduled to open in the first quarter of 2020.
The good news for recovered paper exporters as the calendar flipped to another new year was China's issuance of almost six million short tons worth of import licenses in December. The first batch of permits issued by China's Ministry of the Environment, covering about 5.5 million tons, was more than double the amount of recovered paper allowed by China's first batch a year earlier.
Balcones Resources celebrated its 25th anniversary in business this month, growing from a small Austin-based paper recycler to a comprehensive environmental services company with facilities in Austin, Dallas and Little Rock. Balcones marked the milestone with a reception featuring a presentation of $25,000 in total donations to five Austin-area environmental organizations: EcoRise, Hill Country Conservancy, Keep Austin Beautiful, Shoal Creek Conservancy and Waller Creek Conservancy.
TOMRA Sorting Recycling has announced two additions to their North America product support team. Sean Hyacinth has been added as a field service engineer for TOMRA optical sorting equipment, while Kevin Javier Montalvo assumes the newly created position of customer project manager, recycling. Both team members will work directly with TOMRA dealers and customers to strengthen equipment service and project management throughout North America.
ZenRobotics Ltd. has appointed Wolfgang Schiller as the company's new CEO, effective immediately. Prior to ZenRobotics, Mr. Schiller was the Vice President Electronics Industry at KUKA AG, a leading supplier of intelligent automation solutions. According to ZenRobotics, as CEO, Schiller will be responsible for further developing ZenRobotics' business and accelerating the uptake of intelligent robots in waste management.
In the spring of 2018, Plessisville, Quebec-based Machinex introduced its new SamurAI sorting robot, which, according to the manufacturer, has since generated a lot of industry interest. Nearly six months after its launch, the response of the market has been very positive and nine robots have been sold to date. The first two SamurAI in Canada have just been installed in Quebec while six more robots will be installed by next year in Canadian sorting centers. Moreover, the company says they continue to have regular requests from customers who are greatly interested in this cutting-edge technology.
Greif, Inc., a global provider of industrial packaging products and services, announced December 20 that it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Caraustar Industries, Inc., the leading recycled paperboard and packaging solutions company, from an affiliate of H.I.G. Capital, in a cash transaction valued at $1.8 billion. The transaction is expected to close during the first quarter of calendar year 2019, subject to customary closing conditions, including regulatory clearances.
The Institute of Scrap Recycling Industries (ISRI) recently announced the release of its seventh annual Recycling Industry Yearbook, providing the most up-to-date information and statistics about the U.S. recycling industry and global scrap marketplace. With a greater spotlight on the industry in the wake of rising trade protectionism around the globe, the publication provides the most comprehensive analysis of where the industry stands based on the most current data compared to previous years. It will also serves as a baseline for years to come based on the new global market realities.
The purpose of paper recycling is to produce high quality recycled paper, responding to the high-quality specifications required by paper consumers either from the graphic, hygiene or packaging sectors. In consequence, any collection scheme should be designed in a way to provide grades of paper for recycling adapted to the requirements of high value recycling, according to the EN 643 to the paper industry, either directly or after sorting. (EN 643 is the European List of Standard Grades of Paper and Board for Recycling.)
CP Group, the San Diego-based recycling solutions provider and equipment manufacturer, unveiled their Virtual MRF over a year ago. Now for the first time, it will be on display internationally at Residuos Expo 2018 in Guadalajara, Jalisco Mexico.
TOMRA Collection Solutions has become the first reverse vending provider to offer digital vouchers as a payout option for container deposit schemes, where consumers receive refunds when they return their empty bottles and cans for recycling at a reverse vending machine.