Recycling Product News Logo

This ad will close in 15 seconds

Examining the pros and cons of outbound and inbound blue box processing compensation models

Examining the pros and cons of outbound and inbound blue box processing compensation models

This article is from CIF Connections Blog, October 19, 2018.

The question of how to compensate a MRF service provider is one that was brought up recently in a CIF (Continuous Improvement Fund) blog. In these times of tightening market requirements, municipalities and service providers are rethinking compensation models. Payment against inbound vs outbound tonnage can both work but there are key items that need to be considered, which include the quality and composition of the inbound material and the term of the contract.

Compensation based on Marketed Tonnage is Sensitive to Markets and Material Quality Shifts

Compensation based on outbound, marketed tonnage places the onus on the contractor to maximize the capture of recyclables but also produce a marketable product. However, with this type of contract the contractor is fully exposed to risk and implications associated with an increase in contamination levels or change in the composition of the material. A long-term contract based on marketed tonnes may require the contractor to upgrade the facility at their cost in order to address these unpredictable variables. Not surprisingly, this scenario can lead bidders to increase their initial processing bids to mitigate the risk. It may also lead to mid-contract requests for additional compensation and disputes between the parties, particularly where the contract includes provisions that specify performance requirements such as material capture rates.

Compensation based on Inbound Tonnage Can Reduce the Contractor's Risk

Compensation based on inbound tonnage, on the other hand, may provide greater assurance to the service provider that they will be fairly compensated regardless of inbound quality and inability to market sorted materials in depressed market conditions. This ultimately lowers the service provider's risk and potentially reduce initial bid prices.

However, performance requirements such as capture rates become essential if compensation is based on inbound tonnage. Even with this approach, the contractor will still make assumptions about recovery and revenue so a dramatic change in material quality, composition or market conditions may force them to seek compensation. This risk increases with the length of the contract.

Time is the Enemy

Whether compensation is based on inbound or outbound tonnage, providing a contractor with a longer-term contract gives them the certainty necessary to make and amortize capital investments that ultimately benefit both parties. However, as noted, the risk of material changes to the inbound stream and markets increases with the term of the contract. To combat these risk factors, many municipalities are now considering placing greater assurances on inbound material mix and quality. They're doing this by providing prospective bidders with detailed material composition and compaction rate information through the procurement process and then committing to carrying out waste composition audits over the term of the contract. Ultimately, success is dependent upon:

- a mutual understanding of the audit methodology to be utilized to determine inbound quality;
- a well-defined process to determine what is considered contamination; and
- a clear process to address and for compensation for changes to the inbound PPP stream over the term of the contract.

This is echoed by Paulina Leung of Emterra Group who commented "as service providers we want recycling programs to succeed. Learning from the past and looking into the future, it is therefore important that service agreements provide equity for both parties, assign risk where appropriate, and create conditions for an adaptable and responsible program. We recommend that what this shift will look like be clearly spelled out in the RFP/contract."

More from Waste Diversion

Metso Waste Recycling strengthens sales in North America

Lou Martins is Metso Waste Recycling's new General Sales Manager in North America. Lou brings with him significant experience and a proven track record from the solid waste market, including 6 years with Van Dyk Recycling Solutions. "With Van Dyk Recycling Solutions Lou successfully developed and led a North American solutions initiative for processing and treating a new waste stream for glass.

Animal proof waste & recycling containers are ideal for rural areas

Paris Site Furnishings introduces innovative animal proof waste or recycling containers.  Constructed of galvanized steel, theses durable receptacles will keep out racoons, birds, squirrels, even bears, while dual streams allow for source separation of waste. Available as model BPLR1 - single, 32-gallon capacity units, or as BPLR2 - doubles with 64-gallon capacity.  Dual streams allow users to separate garbage from recycling, organics from plastics, or even pet waste from general waste. Paris Site Furnishings' BPLR models are an ideal waste storage solution for golf courses, campgrounds, parks, apartments, communal sharing by a group of property owners, small businesses, fire departments, community centers or anywhere durable, wildlife resistant waste containers are needed. 

Shell joins as equity partner with Enerkem and others on first-of-its-kind waste-to-chemicals project

A consortium of world-leading companies comprising Montreal-based Enerkem, Air Liquide, Nouryon and the Port of Rotterdam, has announced that Shell will join as a partner in Europe's first advanced waste-to-chemicals facility in Rotterdam, the Netherlands. According to Enerkem, Shell will become an equal equity partner in the proposed commercial-scale waste-to-chemicals (W2C) project, which will be the first of its kind in Europe to make valuable chemicals and bio-fuels out of non-recyclable waste materials.

TOMRA leads BFR sorting technology presentation at IERC 2019

TOMRA Sorting Recycling presented at the influential International Electronics Recycling Congress (IERC 2019), sharing the company's specialized knowledge of materials recovery from electrical and electronic waste (WEEE). With legislation prohibiting the re-use of plastics containing brominated flame retardants (BFRs), TOMRA discussed how combining the company's near infrared and X-Ray technologies enables the removal of up to 98% of plastics containing BFRs from mixed plastic waste streams. 

free-paper-airplane

Get our newsletter

Learn more

​Rubicon Global and State Farm Arena divert nearly 12 tons of waste from landfills

Rubicon Global, the Atlanta-based technology company that provides waste, recycling and smart city solutions to businesses and governments worldwide, has successfully diverted nearly 12 tons of waste destined for landfills from State Farm Arena during last week's festivities in Atlanta, Georgia. This waste was generated as a result of five events being held at the State Farm Arena leading up to and in support of the ‘Big Game.'  

Compology’s in-dumpster cameras and Contamination Score provide path to sustainable, efficient waste collection

Compology, based in San Francisco, got its start in the fall of 2013, with its first camera-based container monitoring system deployed in 2014 at the University of California in Santa Cruz. The system is designed to monitor container fullness and automate the process of container pickups between waste generators and haulers. Today, about a fifth of Compology's business is in Canada, with the remainder in the U.S.

Project to expand glass recycling in Denver

A six-month glass collection pilot project coordinated by Recycle Colorado will increase the collection of glass bottles in downtown Denver. The project provides 96-gallon recycling carts to participating businesses and arranges for glass collection services through May 2019. Businesses can participate for free.

Latest mobile dust suppression design features Tier 4 Final Gen Set

BossTek has updated its family of self-powered dust suppression equipment with Tier IV Final-compliant generators, ensuring compliance in all 50 states and Canada.  BossTek made the announcement with the debut of the new DustBoss DB-60 Fusion, a field-proven suppression system driven by a high-reliability 25 HP electric motor and paired with a gen set powered by a heavy-duty 4-cycle indirect injection diesel engine.  Designed, engineered and assembled in the USA, the generator features a dual-containment fuel cell, heavy gauge lockable enclosure and oversized brushless alternator for easy starting.  

free-magazine-subscription

Get Our Magazine

Paper or Digital delivered monthly to you

Subscribe or Renew Learn more

​Mauser Packaging Solutions introduces first medical waste container made of 100% recycled material

Mauser Packaging Solutions, a global leader in solutions and services across the packaging lifecycle, has launched the first medical waste container made of 100% recycled plastics generated from post-consumer packaging waste. The innovative concept has been awarded the 3rd prize in the 2018 NENnovation Award presented by the Dutch Standardization Institute NEN.

Waste Connections completes previously announced acquisition of American Disposal Services

Toronto-based Waste Connections, Inc. has acquired American Disposal Services, Inc. and certain affiliates, one of the largest privately-owned solid waste collection and recycling businesses in the Mid-Atlantic states.  American has total annualized revenues of approximately $175 million and serves approximately 400,000 customers in Virginia, Maryland, Georgia and Colorado.

Nick Doyle joins TOMRA Sorting Recycling as Sales Manager, West Coast North America

TOMRA Sorting Recycling, the global supplier of sensor-based sorting equipment, announces that Nick Doyle has joined the TOMRA team as Sales Manager, West Coast North America. In this newly created position that expands sales and customer support of TOMRA's equipment to waste and plastics recycling operations, Doyle will consult directly with TOMRA partners and customers to implement the right sorting solution to improve recycling recovery rates, increase product purity and boost profitability. 

Lystek wins multi-year contract with City of Guelph to manage biosolids

Lystek International has announced that on October 24, 2018, a multi-year (up to ten) contract was formally executed between the Cambridge, Ontario-based provider of advanced biosolids management solutions and its long-term customer, the City of Guelph. This is an especially rewarding agreement due to the fact that the first installation of the low-temperature Lystek Thermal Hydrolysis Process (Lystek THP) was demonstrated and commercialized in partnership with the forward-thinking city a little over ten years ago.

X-Cutter system from UNTHA creating waves in European SRF-RDF markets

The X-Cutter (XC) system for the XR waste shredder was first revealed by UNTHA Shredding Technology at the IFAT event in Munich, this past May. Designed to achieve the next generation of performance for single-step SRF shredding - or provide a direct replacement for existing high-speed shredders - it can transform varied input wastes ranging from waste wood through to pulper ropes.

free-paper-airplane

Get our newsletter

Learn more

​TuffBoxx introduces the Camper Dual Stream Waste & Recycling Receptacle

Princeton, Ontario-based TuffBoxx has introduced the Camper, the company's newest dual stream, double door, animal resistant waste or recycling receptacle. Constructed of galvanized steel, the Camper will keep out almost any form of wildlife while dual streams allow for source separation of waste. Available with accessibility compliant "mailbox" style chutes or with top lid access, each Camper holds two 32-gallon containers.  Dual streams allow users to separate garbage from recycling, organics from plastics, or even pet waste from general waste.  The Camper is an ideal waste storage solution for campgrounds, parks, apartments, communal sharing by a group of property owners, small businesses, fire departments, community centers or anywhere durable, wildlife resistant waste containers are needed. 

​Compology bin monitoring technology to help reduce organics contamination and GHG emissions

The Alameda County Waste Management Authority (StopWaste) has been awarded a $263,000 grant by the Bay Area Air Quality Management District to work with Livermore Sanitation, Inc. (LSI) and use Compology's automated, camera-based dumpster monitoring technology to reduce contamination in commercial business compost streams and increase diversion of organics from landfills. Diversion Strategies will oversee the tracking and reporting of progress.

TOMRA's new-generation X-TRACT features dual processing technology, multi-density channels and application packages

TOMRA Sorting Recycling has introduced a new generation of X-TRACT machine with advanced sorting technology that allows a broader range of market segments to take advantage of its ability to boost purity levels. Today's XTRACT features innovative Dual Processing Technology to enhance final purity levels; multi-density channels for more precise classification and sorting of materials; and a broad range of application packages.

GFL Environmental and Waste Industries announce merger

GFL Environmental Inc. ("GFL") based out of Toronto, and Raleigh, North Carolina-based Waste Industries have announced that they have entered into a definitive merger agreement in a transaction that values Waste Industries at a total enterprise value of US$2.825 billion (approximately C$3.65 billion). The transaction, which is expected to close in the fourth quarter of 2018, is subject to customary regulatory approvals. 

​Equipment strategies for increasing hauling revenue and profitability in waste and recycling

It should come as no great shock to hear that the waste management industry is thriving. According to the Environmental Resource and Education Foundation, the solid waste industry contributes nearly $100 billion, one million jobs, and just over one percent of U.S. GDP to the nation's economy. This economic growth fuels demand and results in increased waste generation. 

Building Tomorrow: Volvo goes all in on wheeled excavators for North America

Volvo Construction Equipment demonstrated that they are dedicated to the growing North American wheeled excavator market during their fall press briefing at their Shippensburg, Pennsylvania, manufacturing and customer experience facility. According to the company, the wheeled excavator market in North America is on pace for 23 percent growth in unit sales for 2016–2018, while Volvo is on pace for 60 percent growth in share of total unit sales for North America in 2016–2018. During that time, Volvo has introduced seven new models of wheeled excavator, including three replacement models. These models cover six size classes ranging from the 5- to 9-ton class to the 23-ton class, and include the introduction of Volvo's first dedicated material handler for North America, the EW240EMH.

Recycle Across America launches largest recycling education campaign in U.S. history

In response to the U.S. recycling crisis, 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization Recycle Across America (RAA) has launched the celebrity-led "Let's recycle right!" ("Let's") Campaign, which is the largest recycling education campaign in U.S. history. Many of the campaign's TV/billboard/print/social media ads feature simple tips for proper recycling and introduce a society-wide standardized labeling solution for recycling bins, which "makes it possible for people everywhere to recycle right."  

BPS System Controls designed for recycling equipment and operations

Maximizing productivity is a continuous concern for recycling operations, and the right control system can reduce headaches and streamline processes. According to  Ohio-based Best Process Solutions (BPS), the company's panel-building department can deliver quality controls with seamless integration into an existing system, or custom-designed, for a complete recycling line from beginning to end. 

free-magazine-subscription

Get Our Magazine

Paper or Digital delivered monthly to you

Subscribe or Renew Learn more